Home > Online Reputation, Online Reputation Management > “If I’m Good, My Online Reputation Doesn’t Matter”

“If I’m Good, My Online Reputation Doesn’t Matter”

December 23rd, 2013

That’s the thought behind Darren Slatten’s post on an SEOMoz and it’s a valid point to consider.  If an individual is so good at what they do that they are constantly turning down new clients anyway, does it matter if the #2 result for your name says, Darren Slatten Sucks – Don’t Ever Hire Him?

Darren’s point is that as long as you come through for your clients, you will always be in demand and they will dismiss any negative information they find while searching for you.  In essence, Darren is saying that word of mouth and a referral from a trusted friend holds more weight than the Internet.   Assuming business is great and will stay that way, I’d say he’s right.

The trouble is, at some point, someday, business may not be as plentiful and easy to come by.  SEO is a huge topic and thousands of websites are clamoring for good people to help them rank higher in the search engines – and there aren’t enough people who can deliver real results to go around.  But at some point, either the need for SEO help will diminish or the number of good SEO experts will grow, making it more difficult to rely entirely on referrals to build a business.  That’s when your online reputation could start to hurt you rather than help.

You may not need Google now, but do you really want to risk the chance of losing business when you need it 5 or 10 years from now?  Seems like the quintessential “burning of bridges” to me.  Darren’s got cajones – I’ll give him that.

Tony Adam, in a rebuttal post, has some good points.

Online reputation also becomes an important consideration for family businesses.  Anyone who has plans of passing their company on to the next generation has an obligation to them as well to ensure they benefit from a solid reputation we have left behind for them online.  We die, but the bits and bytes we leave behind never do.

Update: Darren was right – his post is ranking at #2 on Google.  Yikes!

Darren Slatten

Darren Slatten

  1. April 23rd, 2009 at 21:13 | #1

    I can see what you’re saying here:

    “But at some point, either the need for SEO help will diminish or the number of good SEO experts will grow, making it more difficult to rely entirely on referrals to build a business.”

    …but I think the opposite sounds just as reasonable:

    As the number of SEO companies increases, business owners will have more access to first-hand referrals and recommendations from friends and colleagues, making the business owners less likely to rely on Google when searching for an SEO company.

    An example to support this theory would be the medical field. Everyone has health issues at some point, so when a person is “shopping” for a new doctor, they can simply ask their friends and family for suggestions and expect that virtually all of them have some kind of opinion to share.

    I guess the question is… who would you hire?

    ApplicantA:

    – Personally recommended by someone you know.
    – Google returns some anti-ApplicantA results from people you don’t know.

    ApplicantB:

    – Not recommended by anyone you know.
    – Google returns pro-ApplicantB results from people you don’t know.

    But yeah… nice post. I think you did an excellent job of translating my post into coherent arguments. Well done. =)

  2. April 24th, 2009 at 04:38 | #2

    @Darren Slatten
    Good points Darren. It’s an interesting argument. I guess my answer would be Applicant C:

    – good referrals from friends and business colleagues
    AND
    – when I look them up in Google I find positive information

    Thanks for the comment!